The Beaver (2011) -vs- Lars and the Real Girl (2007)
Step aside Wilson and Harvey â€” here come Bianca and the Beaver in a couple of remarkable movies that feature inanimate creatures as key co-stars. Bianca and the Beaver â€” thereâ€™s probably a good joke or two there somewhere, but, surprisingly, these films are not comedies.
Both The Beaver and Lars and the Real Girl are each based on a highly regarded, original screenplay â€” the first was Oscar nominated, the most recent one once famously topped Hollywoodâ€™s â€œBlack Listâ€ for best unproduced script. And neither movie relies on CGI â€” now that is remarkable.
Both films explore the complexity of extreme personal demons brought on by feelings of loneliness, isolation and depression. Each one has also been accused of being over-the-top: their lead characters certainly have the potential to come across not so much compelling as uncomfortable. And there is the Mel Gibson-factor.
So itâ€™s a testament to the screenwriters, the directors and the actors that both motion pictures are also solid dramas with heart and soul. They are character-studies of two men seeking to re-discover themselves, their families and the outside world. […]